“THE
POSTER”
Posters are 4 ft. x 3 ft. The backs for posters are available
free from Detlef Ott in Keck B05.
As the posters may be put up around the department for a year, materials
should be well anchored on posters; instead of pins, use fold over
fasteners.
Look at the existing posters for ideas. The following information
is designed to help you to be successful.
A few tips for successful posters:
• Make
sure everything is there – name, institution, abstract, references
cited and acknowledgments.
• Pay
careful attention to the size of the lettering. Title and main heading
should be visible from two meters text from one meter. This means at
least 18 pt. type for the main text.
• Give
the reader clear clues as to the order of the text – three columns
left to right is most conventional, but other arrangements will work
with some thought.
• Use
graphs, outlines, graphics, and lists wherever possible to make a point. Avoid
too much lengthy text.
• Make
sure that all the various pieces of paper are firmly glued (rubber
cement is good for this) and square with each other. Best
to use a T-square for this.
• Color
for backing and “framing” text is useful, but avoid anything too distracting
or arty. Backing white paper with contrasting poster board is
highly effective.
• Construction
paper, marker, crayon, and hand-lettering are to be avoided if at all
possible. Remember, the impression to be sought is scientific
professionalism, not science fair.
Combating Poster Fatigue:
Better Visual Communications
by Employing Visual “Grammar” and Analysis
by
John D. Woolsey, College of Art and Design,
University of the Art, Philadelphia
and
Bette Woolsey, J/B Woolsey Association, Bala Cynwyd, PA
(Sponsored by NIMB-DBS)
An educational display for the 17th Annual Meetings
of the Society for Neuroscience November 16-21, 1987, New Orleans,
LA
INTRODUCTION
It is clear that
the poster session has become a permanent fixture at scientific meetings. Lack
of enough meeting rooms and time slots for slide presentations has made
them a necessity. Although the poster session early on gained a
bad reputation (largely because of the labor involved in producing it)
we have seen this format increasingly employed even at smaller meetings
and in house symposia because it affords certain strong advantages in
communicating with one’s colleagues.
ADVANTAGES OF POSTER SESSIONS
Posters are on
display for several hours, allowing time for lengthy discussions with
one’s colleagues It is this opportunity for dialogue which has
made them popular at smaller meetings where lack of lecture facilities
is not a problem. Data and graphics on the poster are available
as long as individual viewers wish to see them. The viewer may
focus on that which is of most interest. For instance, description
of technique may be of prime interest to one viewer, whereas data analysis
may be of interest to another.
Though posters
are almost always arranged sequentially, they allow the viewer to go
back and review a figure or some text earlier in the sequence at will.
Posters have graphic
flexibility. The ease of creating color graphics, combinations
of photographic and graphic techniques, computer graphics, and outputs
from recording devices, as well as the removal of the limitation of the
2-unit-by-3-unit slide format increases the range of graphic flexibility
available to the creator. Even three-dimensional elements may be
used.
The poster may
be studied in detail for taking notes. Some viewers photograph
sections or whole posters that interest them. One photographic
method of producing posters enables the printing of inexpensive facsimiles
as handouts.
Posters enhance
collegial dialogue. A slide presentation usually includes five
minutes for questions and answers, whereas the length of a poster presentation
assures virtually unlimited time for dialogue with one’s colleagues. For
younger researchers this dialogue may provide important contacts with
colleagues who might miss a slide lecture. A poster frequently
elicits valuable responses from scientists outside the immediate field
who may have specific ideas regarding technique, analytical methods or
the like, but who would not attend a lecture on the topic being presented.
DISADVANTAGES OF POSTER
SESSIONS
Posters are labor
intensive primarily because of their size and the requirement for large
text. This guide contains suggestions for keeping this labor to
a minimum.
Poster production
requires materials which are generally more expensive than slides such
as large prints, title banners, mat boards and the like. These
expenses can be minimized with careful planning.
A poster is bulkier
than 10-15 slides. While we have heard many complaints about carrying
posters to meetings, we have never heard one complaint about lugging
skis to winter conferences!
Though posters
are generally used for one meeting only, there are methods of attaching
graphic materials to the poster so they may be reused in other poster
publications.
AUDIENCE
ANALYSIS
The audience for
a poster may be divided into three major groups:
Group 1 are
those colleagues, collaborators and students who follow your work very
closely. These are the people who read your publications in detail
and who correspond with you. They may number a handful or a few
dozen. A crudely constructed poster would not daunt them because
of their high level of interest in your area of specialization.
Group 2, a
much larger group, is made up of those scientists who work in the same
general area as you, but on different subspecialties. This audience
may which to review large numbers of communications in their area, but
with less attention to detail. Nevertheless, because of their general
knowledge of the field, they may provide valuable suggestions and insight
about your research.
Group 3,
perhaps the largest group, are those researchers whose work bears little
or no relationship to yours. Successful communication on a more
general level can take place with this group if they can be enticed to
view your poster briefly.
It is indeed possible
to design a poster which effectively communicates with all three audiences
without slighting the other. It can be economical and relatively
easy to construct, made as permanent or temporary as is required.
The following
is a detailed consideration for the graphic elements that make up a poster;
how to organize the text, illustrations and other graphic elements into
a cohesive whole for easy comprehension, and how to communicate your
research findings with immediacy and clarity.
LAYOUT
A scale-model
layout acts as an outline and is the best way to plan your poster. It
significantly saves times and expense while affording the opportunity
to revise and refine ideas. A layout should determine the size
of art and photography, length of text, headings, and flow of information
before the final production of any tone element. Visualizing a
poster in its entirety at the planning stage is a must. Information
will become apparent and editing can take place. In the end, the
actual time spent putting the poster together will decrease significantly
with better results.
There are two
basic stages to preparing a layout; the “thumbnail”, and the tight layout.
The thumbnail
layout is a rough, quick, small sketch which is meant to work the basic
flow of information in the poster and map out its visual logic. Thumbnails
may be done without much regard to the actual amounts of text, but on
should have a relatively clear idea of the number and relative sizes
of the illustrations, photographs and diagrams to be included. (The
Neuroscience posters are 2 units by 3 wide, so thumbnails could be 4”x6”). Several
thumbnail alternatives can be worked out in a few minutes each. They
are your loose visual outlines.
After preparing
the thumbnail layouts, one arrangement will seem the best to pursue further. At
this point, it is necessary to determine approximately how much text
copy there is. We’ll assume that the text will be printed from
a word processing file and enlarged on an office copier. Since,
to be legible at the optimum of 3’-4’, the text must be enlarged 2 diameters,
one needs to bear in mind the largest paper that the copier can handle. A
line to be enlarged 8” on the poster should be 4’ on the draft copy (40
characters of 10 pitch type or 48 characters of 12 pitch type). By
reformatting your files to these widths you will have an accurate picture
of the amount of space to be allotted for type. If you are typing
the copy manually, multiply the average draft line length in characters
by the number of lines and divide by the proposed new line length in
characters to calculate the number of new lines. This will give
the vertical measure of the copy.
You may be surprise
to find that your text occupies much more space than you anticipated. Remember,
that the poster is essentially a visual presentation, that there is a
lots of competition for the reader’s attention, and that generally where
text is concerned, less is more, so edit text at this stage.
The section ton
text will suggest an approach to maximize communication to all three
audience groups.
A convenient method
of preparing the tight layout is as follows:
1. A
scale of ¼” = 1” is a convenient working size for a layout. On
a sheet of ¼” graph paper measure the outside dimensions of your poster. Outline
it heavily.
2. Divide
the rectangle vertically in thirds or fourths. These divisions
suggest possible columns to follow in the layout and , later, logical
divisions for cutting and folding the finished poster. They may
be suggested by your thumbnail sketch.
3. Draw
a horizontal line 1.5”-2” from the top for the title area.
4. Use
paper cut to scale to represent graphics and photos as well as text. For
instance a number of pieces of paper representing 5x7 prints or 8x10
graphs can be cut out. These paper elements can easily be moved
around and various alternatives can be compared by taping down the results
temporarily and Xeroxing them. Use scraps of photographic prints
or pictures and text from magazines to help give a more realistic visual
sensation of the finished product.
The tight layout
is the working blueprint for your poster. From here on, there should
be few significant changes and the poster can be produced easily by simply
transferring the measurements multiplied by 4.
COMPOSITION
Composition
is the visual structure of a poster: it should aid, not interfere with
comprehension.
The purpose of
composition is to make visual ideas blow smoothly and logically from
one to the other, to visually subordinate those things which are less
important and to draw attention to those things which are of greater
importance.
A poster cannot
be “figured out” at the leisurely pace that a paper can. It is
presented for several hours, often amid crowded conditions, and with
many other competing presentations. It is essential that
it contain no nonessential visual elements. Edit ruthlessly!
A good composition
has a substantial amount of blank space, often close to 50%. This
space can be used to highlight section break. A “full” poster does
not always make its point. It is often too chaotic to follow easily.
Some good suggestions
for composing materially visually:
1. Groups
of related information function best if tightly composed with a clear
surround.
2. Long
visual lines help organize groups of information:
- align X or Y axes in groups of graphs;
- align edges in groups of photographs;
- align headings and text material.
3. Close
positioning of an illustration and its text make it a visual unit. Jagged
compositions make the eye dance around in a restless fashion and draw
attention away from content. The eye looks for edges. A poster
which is composed of squares of white paper, neatly mounted on colored
boards which are then mounted on a colored board’s surface has many useless
and distracting edges with which to contend. If these boards, in
turn, are of varying sizes or are not mounted perfectly straight,
the added jags in the composition take more attention away from the content. Compositions
which are aligned on imaginary center lines often have this jaggy appearance.
BACKGROUND COLOR AND MATERIALS
A single
background color (or closely related set of colors) serves to unify a
poster and clearly distinguish it from neighboring posters.
Colors which are
somewhat muted or grayed provide a more restful background than do bright
colors. In a brightly lit hall crowded with other posters and people,
such color is more likely to bring attention to your work.
Color can be used
to unify groups of data. Three colors of similar value and saturation
(e.g., a green-gray, blue-gray and violet-gray) might serve as backgrounds
to help tie together the methods, data and interpretations of three related
experiments. Such use enhances graphic meaning.
Color can enhance
the hues or contrast of photographs: dark photos will look darker on
a light background, lighter on a dark background (law of simultaneous
contrasts); color photos will look more colorful when displayed on a
neutral background (like medium gray), less colorful on white.
Art supply and
frame shops carry a variety of mat boards. Mat board is superior
to thin poster board (railroad board) not only because the color selection
is better but because it doesn’t fade, the surface is less fragile allowing
erasures and repositioning of mounted items) and its larger size is less
wasteful.
TITLE
The title
announces you and your work at 15-20’: it should be assertive, clear
and eye-catching.
Titles which actively
state findings of the research are prefer passive titles (“Studies of…”). It
need not use more than 6”-8” at the top of the poster since if it is
lower, it may be obscured by heads. Contrast is essential for clarity. This
does not preclude using color, however.
Title type need
be no larger than 1 ¼” – 1 ¾” high; authors and affiliations should be
about 1” high. Caps and lower case is preferred to all caps. Affiliations
may be very abbreviated as they are available in the published abstracts. Abstract
numbers should be 2”-3” tall.
Including an abstract
copy (often suggested in instructions to authors) is rarely necessary
because its content is usually repeated in the text of the poster and
is redundant.
A border around
the title copy provides “breathing room” for the copy and helps readability.
Consideration
should be given to altering the title so that it contributes to understanding
the research. Thus, the title:
“Studies of the
Effect of Compound XYZ on Caudal Motor Neurons in the Dog”
might be changed
to a more declarative style which actually communicates some portion
of the conclusion:
“Compound XYZ
Causes Tail – Wagging in Dogs”
Similarly, names
and affiliations may be shortened when they are too wordy or where details
are self-evident. Middle initials may be dropped from names; cities
may be dropped from well known affiliations (for instance, New Haven
would be dropped from Yale University); state names may be eliminated. (Philadelphia
is sufficient, but Miami should include OH if it is not the one in FL!);
departments may often be eliminated. Multiple affiliations should
be handled in the most direct fashion, each affiliation following the
appropriate author rather than employing elaborate footnote schemes which
are more appropriate to publication.
Where space is
available, an author’s first name rather than initials would be useful,
helping the direct dialogue with the presenter.
Deciding whether
to center the lines of the title text or to align them left or right
is best done in the layout. Lettering techniques may determine
the best method: professional typesetting can produce centered text with
ease as can most computer generated systems. Vinyl letters and
hand lettering are more difficult to center. If the job is not
done perfectly, errors are glaring.
Color for a title
banner is limited by contrast between the type and the background. High
contrast is necessary for reading from a distance and the ability to
use color on the title banner may be determined by the technique used
to produce it. Because of the bright, flat light in convention
halls and the prevalence of other black and white presentations, using
some color in the title is recommended.
The use of logos
on posters with corporate affiliations may be required by their companies,
but should be kept to a scale consistent with the text size. School
letters and mascots have little meaning to anyone outside that institution
and their use is questionable.
TEXT
The
text, hierarchically organized, must integrate with illustrations, photographs
and tables; it usually can be drawn from the abstract.
Main
heads carry essential content, and should provide a complete “take-home” message. The
main methods, results and conclusions should be clear to casual viewers. To
be read from 6’-8’ away, type must be about 10mm high. Numbers
for each section of the poster should be approximately 2” high and will
guide the eye to proper sequence.
Supporting
text follows main heads. It should be visible at 3’-4’, with type
about 5mm high, and heads should describe each figure in sufficient detail
to support its significance and relationship to the main heads. Details,
also to be read at 3’-4’ should be subordinated to sub-heads in placement
(e.g., lower right vs. upper left), be a lighter weight or have a less
prominent background color.
Reliance
on verbal descriptions, with references to figure numbers, while appropriate
for publications, defeats the purpose of a poster, which is to display ideas.
Your
poster is not a publication of record. It is not necessary to describe
methods exhaustively or to provide massive tables of data or elaborate
statistical analyses. Text which concentrates on these things makes
a poster more inaccessible. An observer who is concerned enough
will generally ask about this information, and more detailed material
can be discussed or provided in a handout.
Text
should be purged of redundancy and should be written to eliminate copy
which is meaningless in itself (“see Fig. #…..”).
Text
should be rendered compactly in easy to read type.
1. Caps
and lower case is easier to read than all caps. Avoid using.
2. Serif
styles scan more easily than sanserif styles especially in longer passages.
3. Line
length should not exceed 65 characters. Lines should be single
spaced. Type in uneven length lines (Flush-left, ragged right)
scans better than justified type.
4. Professional
typesetting or laser printer fonts are most legible, and, depending on
the font chosen, are generally more compact than typing. When type
is to be read at a distance, this quality is all the more important. Recommended
are Times Roman or Garamond type, or Courier and Prestige typewriter
or printer fonts.
5. Open,
round letters are preferred to condensed, small bodied letters.
6. All
text copy should be at least 5mm high (about 2X typewriter size).
7. Good,
clear hand-printing is preferred to type which is too small, too light
(as basic dot-matrix renditions), or inappropriate fonts, such as Old
English.
8. Computer
generated text may be easily reformatted to accommodate the layout, and
many typographers can set type inexpensively directly from your diskettes
or via modem.
ILLUSTRATIONS
AND PHOTOGRAPHY
Illustrations
and tables usually hold the main content of a successful poster, showing
rather than telling a story.
Graphics must
dominate. Text should be used to augment, not overwhelm, illustrations.
For clarity, all
nonessential information should be removed from figures, such as data
lines not considered in the text, elaboration of statistical analysis,
etc. Keys should be replaced with direct labeling.
The same version
of an illustration does not always serve all purposes well. A graph
prepared for publication may have symbols and a key for significant values,
standard error bars or data lines included for reasons apparent in the
publication, but not so obvious in a poster. A graphic does not
gain scientific veracity simply because it has been drawn professionally
or preferable to an overloaded figure, even if professionally drawn.
Color may easily
be added to illustrations with overlay films, colored tapes and markers
(use water-base markers or Xerox materials), and black and white figures
may be copied into colored papers on most office copiers.
1. Data
lines should be bold or colored with markers or tapes.
2. Diagrams
using shaded areas should rely on differences of value (lightness and
darkness) rather than pattern to be clearly contrasted. Open bars
should be avoided
3. Thin
looking figures composed with a computer can be augmented with color,
using adhesive color overlays or markers.
4. Borders
on illustrations should be reduced to about ¼” except where a constant
shape is less distracting in an array.
5. Flow
charts may frequently be executed in small units tied together by tape
or marker arrows. Shaped elements can be cut out of their backgrounds
to contrast with the rectangles that usually dominate a poster.
6. Photographic
detail, especially in EM’s, must be enlarged enough to be seen from 3’-4’,
even if this results in “empty” enlargement. Photos should not
be overly contrasted, but should have a “snappy” appearance.
7. Color
photographs enhance a poster, but need not be used if black and white
communicates a point equally well. Black and white photos may be
colored with transparent markers and adhesive overlays to call attention
to certain details.
8. Color
originals of average brightness range usually yield satisfactory prints
from photo finishers. However, problematic originals must be printed
by custom houses. When in doubt, plan your poster pictures early
enough to order color prints first from a photo finisher and then from
a custom house if necessary. In smaller cites, prints from color
slides often must be sent back to Kodak or some larger facility for processing,
taking 7-10 days. These prints are relatively inexpensive because
they are produced on automatic equipment which is calibrated to produce
the best results for standard snapshot subject matter. A very light
original will frequently be rendered dark and brownish. Conversely,
a dark original will often have a greenish cast and decreased color saturation. These
problematic originals must be sent to custom labs which print by hand. Good
communication with the lab detailing what is important in the photo will
help yield the best results. Most custom labs work quickly, in
24 to 72 hours, and are expensive.
ADDING
GRAPHIC EMPHASIS
“Dressing up” a
poster helps ease reading and comprehension.
Colored borders,
bullets and blocks can call attention to specific text or figures. Drop
shadows of cut paper, chart tapes or marker can make artwork appear to
pop out form the surface. 3-D mounting dramatizes photographs and other
pictorial materials.
PRODUCTION
TECHNIQUES
Many good production
techniques are easy, familiar and readily available.
Through professional
artists use a number of techniques which seem mysterious to the scientist,
most laboratories and academic locations have easy access to the following
technologies, supplies and services which make poster production easy
for the non-artist. Bear in mind again that the most graphic impact
of a poster comes not form the neatness of its execution, but from its
graphic planning.
1. Text
can be produced on typewriters or computers and enlarged on copiers.
2. Title
banners can be printed with computer “sign” programs, vinyl or die-cut
letters. The computer output may be enhanced with colored markers,
overlay sheets or pencils.
3. Figures
may be plotted by computer and enhanced by hand using the color techniques
above.
4. Photographic
prints or Photostats are readily available to most labs.
5. Using
the layout as a guide, mounting boards may be cut to size, and layout
measurements easily transferred in soft pencil and erased after the poster
elements are affixed.
6. Rubber
cement or glue stick may be used for temporary affixing, and elements
of the poster may be “tipped in” by simply gluing the top edge and allowing
the bottom to fall free, if desired. Mounting adhesive tissue such
as 3M Positional Mounting Adhesive, should be used where permanence
is desired. Items needing later reuse can be slipped into acetate
sheet protectors glued to the mounting boards or with “photo album corners” made
of paper or acetate.
7. Employing
a columnar layout of 20”-24” units wide in sections 12”-18” deep and hinged
with tape on the back, a poster can be transported easily, assembled
instantly, and avoid damage in transport. All elements will be
in precise position and the author may attend to questions from viewers
immediately.
8. Cardboard
packing approximately 2” larger in each dimension than the poster will
minimize damage and bent corners.
IN SUMMARY,
a poster with visual clarity can be produced successfully by:
1. Assembling
illustrations and text into a layout
2. Editing
text for brevity hierarchy and efficiency
3. Integrating
text and illustrations
4. Composing
in long lines and groups with adequate blank spaces
5. Keeping
consistent scale in text and figures
6. Making
good use of color in backgrounds and figure enhancements
7. Producing
all elements to actual size before assembling
8. Making
the poster foldable and portable
|